Tuesday, 11 August 2015

India’s rising economic clout: Government’s hardwork or sheer luck?

We all remember the 90’s cult movie “Border”, right. Let’s revisit the theme of the movie once.

A brave Major Kuldeep Singh (Sunny Deol) voluntarily led a team of 100 odd soldiers to fight the Pakistan army. They grossly underestimated the number of Pakistan’s soldiers and tanks; however, still fought valiantly to defend their turf. In the end, Indian Air Force showed their might, and Pakistan’s tanks were sitting ducks in front of them. Thereafter, it was a cakewalk for Indians. Refreshing memory ha!!

But the hard truth is, doesn’t matter how brave his decision was to fight that night, if it was not for the external help he got from Indian Air Force, there was no chance Major Kuldeep Singh would have won the battle.

Ironically, Indian economy has witnessed the same theme, although with different characters, in the last 1.5 years.

Confused?? Let me clear the air.

In a historic election last year, we elected the NDA government with a thumping majority making Narendra Modi the charming PM of the country. He promised to expunge corruption from the country, remove red-tape, and elevate India into a new phase of economic development. In nutshell, he promised the moon.   

However, no one could have imagined the things which unravelled during the first year of his government. All major economic reform bills i.e. GST, DTC, mining and land acquisition failed to see the fresh air. The rising nuisance of “rightest” fringe elements created an atmosphere of disharmony in the country for time being. And recently, a spate of corruption charges against some of the familiar faces stirred the hornets’ nest.         

So, how did India still manage to balance its deteriorating financials, and become an investment magnet when other BRICS economies were floundering?

Well, the answer lies with our long-standing enemy, which recently became our friend.

!!BLACK GOLD!!

India, being an emerging country, needs substantial amount of oil and gas to fuel its economy. However, it produces only 20-25% of its requirements domestically, and relies extensively on imported fuel. We are also among the world’s top 5 importers of crude oil.

However, with crude prices declining from a high of $114 per barrel in June 2014 to less than $40 per barrel at present (as explained in my previous blog), it acted as a panacea for the domestic economy in two ways:
-                    Investment magnet: Low crude prices resulted in substantial decline in imports bill and current        account deficit, which in-turn amounted to rising forex reserves. High forex reserves stabilized            the Indian currency and improved credit ratings which made us an investment magnet.
-                   Domestic inflation: Low fuel costs led to subdued domestic inflation in the country. This scenario      increased the effective consumption/spending power of our population, and also prompted the RBI      to cut interest rates and spur economic growth.

Parallely, against the drought prediction of IMD, average monsoon showers in the country is expected to bolster the rural spending power, further helping the upswing in domestic economy.    

The positive aftereffects of these factors have made India the most attractive destination among the so called BRICS nations. While Brazil and Russia are struggling because of low oil prices (both are net exporters of crude oil), China is going through one of its worst slumps with lowest GDP growth rate (7.6% in 2014) in a quarter century. (China’s stock market also crashed by more than 30% in last one month) Although India is on the path of economic glory, it will not be apt to give all the credit to external factors.  

As Indian Air Force could not have done much if Major Kuldeep Singh and other soldiers haven’t stopped the Pakistan’s army till morning, low oil prices alone wouldn’t have lifted the economy if it was not for the efforts of our government.

Narendra Modi’s resolve for “Make in India” plan, and his numerous foreign tours have solidified his image as a global leader, and helped bring billions of dollars in FDI into the country. Substantial government investment in capital goods, power and infrastructure industry, and fast track e-auction of coal mines are also expected to further lift the economy.     

Although numerous examples suggest that government has done the hard work to strengthen the economy, there is absolutely no second opinion on the fact that without the help of external factors, government’s measures alone would not have uplifted the economy.

But I am an optimistic person. I believe that luck only favours those who are determined enough to take some action. Not everyone get a second chance to prove themselves. But Mr Modi has received one to again prove his worth.

The question is not “will the oil prices rise or not”, the question is “when”!! Prices are bound to rise in future casting doubts on the country’s recovery again. The job ahead of our government is to leverage the current slump and push towards building solid fundamentals for the economy. Immunity from external shocks will strengthen our economy, and inspire us into a different league of growth.

PS: These are my personal views. Do comment if you agree or differ from the above reasoning.   
If you like what you are reading, do follow me on twitter at https://twitter.com/handa_ka_funda. Also check out my archives for older work.  

Sunday, 18 January 2015

India’s tryst with the digital services world: A matter of confidence

In the primary school, we learnt that Earth revolves around the sun and is controlled by it. However, in 21st century, Earth is no longer controlled by the Sun, but by Internet. During the last decade, no other industries have demonstrated the widespread impact and reach which is achieved by the digital services industry. It is reshaping our lives in a manner not even imagined by us 10 years back. The revolution has created online behemoths such as Google, Facebook, Amazon, Yahoo etc which virtually control our online and offline life.

Unsurprisingly, India is not an exception. With more than 200 million internet users, India is expected to become second largest internet population of the world by 2015 end. Our country is already one of the largest markets for Facebook, Google, Uber, Amazon and others. But are we really prepared for mass adoption of such services? Is our legal system adept enough to tackle the new age services’ nuances?

You would have hoped that the answer is yes, but actually it is a big NO. Let’s take stock of some incidents.

Youtube: A short clip of a Doordarshan anchor went viral after she introduced the “Governor of Goa” as “Governor of India”. Since that day, her family is trying to bring down that video from Youtube, but to no avail. Although the video is maligning her reputation, police officials can’t take action on it as they have no control over the servers of Youtube.

Ecommerce: Ever wonder what will happen if you unfortunately got delivered a damaged product after paying the amount online? If the supplier is credible, he will take cognizance of the issue and deliver a new one. But what if he is not? What if you get stuck with a damaged product? How can you claim the amount?

File a case!!! Surprisingly, we still have no laws under our legal system to deal with ecommerce companies. It is still work in progress. And to be honest, major ecommerce players such as Flipkart, Amazon and Snapdeal are just market places and not sellers. (Though they supply products under the guise of some subsidiaries) They only bring buyers and sellers under one roof, and absolves themselves from responsibilities related to product quality and related issues.

Uber: The latest euphoria for online cab aggregators is the final nail in the coffin. After the Uber rape incident was reported by the survivor, Delhi police couldn’t take any action for some hours as they were not aware where to go and whom to arrest since the website enlists no office address. Funnily enough, they had to book a cab on Uber and interrogated the driver to reach the company officials. (And we assume that a digital world is a connected world!!)

All three examples point toward the inability of current judicial or legal systems to tackle the new age internet services infrastructure and irresponsible behaviour of the service providers. But my focus is not only on current system, but also on the persons working in it. How can we expect our police department to solve digital services related cases when they themselves are not aware of the new technologies common people are using? Yes, digital services have made the lives of common people easy and enjoyable, but on the contrary, it has also created huge problems for our judicial/regulatory system. They are caught pants down and are now running against time to ensure a secure future for us.

Social networking got prominence in our country through Orkut during the last decade. But it took ages for our police department to take cognizance of its prominence and form a concrete mechanism to tackle social networking related crimes. The police/judicial system could have afforded the time gap in that case, but the margin of error is very less today. Social networking sites were just a tool to connect people, but services like e-commerce are serial business. They contribute toward the country’s economy and are expected to become the next growth drivers for our country. The stakes are very high this time.


People extensively use e-commerce and aggregator services because they have confidence in the service provider. But currently, that confidence is hanging with a very thin thread. If our authorities do not come to terms with this ticking time bomb, it won’t take too long to bust. “It takes years to gain someone’s confidence, but only one bad incident to ruin it.” I hope that our "Tryst with Digital service world" is as magnificent as the vision portrayed by our Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru in his famous speech titled “India’s Tryst with destiny”.