Not long back, there was a famous saying “When US sneezes, world catches fever”.
The fact got proved numerous times in the past when recession in US led to
global economic downturn. However, with the advent of China as a global
superpower in 21st century, the sneezing phrase got a new addition.
And guess what!! China has already sneezed.
But not at once now, it has been sneezing from some time
(probably months). So, why the global economy didn’t take notice of it in the
past, and started panicking only recently?
The answer is “Perception”. Confused? Let me
elaborate.
Some months back, Grexit was the most popular theme on the
internet. Everyone was fixated on whether Greece would announce bankruptcy and exit
Eurozone or not. All major leaders and countries around the world were asking
Europe to find a practical solution to the issue. Greece’s banks were closed
for more than three weeks, and limits were established on withdrawal of money from
ATM machines to stop exodus of capital from the country. Late night round table
discussions among the European leaders to solve the crisis were becoming a
norm.
Meanwhile, thousands of miles away, China’s economy was
scripting a different story of sorts. After a whopping 150% rise in Shanghai
stock market during 2014-15, the concerns regarding stock market bubble were
starting to surface, and the market started its downward trend, culminating
into a disaster in January 2016 with more than 7% decline on two separate days
in a week. The country’s GDP growth rate in the first half of 2015 (7%) was the
lowest in a decade. China’s imports were dipping, and so were its exports.
But, surprisingly, China’s woes were overlooked as economists
perceived
Grexit to be a bigger worry than China. The world’s focus was on Europe,
and no one was monitoring China. And now, everyone is caught up in the wrong
place.
Yes, Europe is an important cog in world economy!
Yes, Grexit may have led to crack in European Union and made
it vulnerable!
But the exit of small and less significant countries
(Greece, Portugal, Slovenia etc.) from European Union should not had been given
prominence over the world’s second largest economy’s deteriorating condition.
Because China is not falling alone, but taking a host of countries down with it.
Large commodity exporting economies such as Canada, Australia and other African
countries are facing recessionary pressures due to their over exposure to China
for exports.
So, the question begs, would it have mattered if we had got
China right?
Probably, No. Because
the fundamentals were anyway going bad.
But, does perception ever matter? The answer is “Yes”.
If China goes down, the world will perceive that all
emerging economies will go bad. Yes, Russia and Brazil are in recession
already, however, this perception may also take India down with it,
notwithstanding its strong economic fundamentals.
Let’s check some facts.
Recently, India became the fastest growing major economy of
the world. The current ultra-low oil price environment has squeezed the
country’s import bill substantially, in turn helping in current account deficit
and strengthen the currency. The country’s national debt is still less than
other large emerging economies, current government’s push for infrastructure
development and Make In India initiatives are expected to revive manufacturing
industry providing jobs to the millions. Our capital market is still very much
immune to the “hot money” (money borrowed at ultra-low interest rates which
find its way into equity markets) which took US and Chinese markets down.
Almost every large brokerage house in the world is expecting India to be partially
immune to the global slowdown due to its strong fundamentals.
We know the fundamentals are good, economists know this, even
global brokerage houses know this. But still, if a global powerhouse like China
goes down, the so called economic perception will take everyone down with it,
not withstanding other factors.
If you still believe the whole economic perception theory is
hoax, explain me why “Just when 2008 financial crisis started, the investors almost
immediately withdrew their money from almost every country in the world and put
it in The US treasury. Yes, the very country which started the depression,
whose housing market got busted, where thousands of people were getting pink
slips every day, whose stock market had collapsed.” It was only because of a perception
that “US can’t fail”.
History always repeats itself, and it may very well repeat
in future too!!
PS: These are my personal views. Do comment if you agree or differ from the above reasoning.
If you like what you are reading, do follow me on twitter at https://twitter.com/handa_ka_funda. Also check out my archives for older work.
A very nice article on the current global economic meltdown.
ReplyDeleteI would also like to share my views on the situation.
While we are focusing on China and USA, we need to look at the broader image. Europe's economy has become stagnant, Middle East is in fix with itself as well as USA. Then there is this problem of terrorism in Syria and North, North Western African countries. All these have accumulated to create the problem for the whole world. We, the Indians in spite of all the turmoil are doing relatively well (still below the potential).
Sir, now I would like to discuss how can India strengthen its position? What could be the possible steps and measures which would help our country to emerge as an economic power?
Very aptly put Rohit. The current situation in Middle East is a great worrry. Plus Europe hasn't really been able to get back after 2008 crisis. And if you see, the famous BRICS economies are also struggling now. Only India is standing tall in them. Our governance structures are improving, focus is not shifting on implementation of project rather than just announcing. And i believe that our current RBI governer is controlling the capital market beautifully, and its highly unlikely that any catastrophic turmoil will happen in India. However, withstanding all the facts, perception is a phenomenon which can't be underestimated. Yes, there will be impact on India, we are not immune, but what we can do is shied ourself to the maximum and jump back quickly. And with such strong macroeconomic fundamentals and domestic demand, i am quite certain that we will.
DeleteAnd i am very much willing to discuss with you the broader events around the blog. May on a different chat platform, but would love to have a chat around it.
DeleteGreat article!! well captured...
ReplyDeleteThank you so much buddy!!
DeleteVery well written my friend!
ReplyDeleteThank you Anuj. Will try to maintain the consistency to write, and hopefully will come out with something more interesting in future.
DeleteVery well written my friend!
ReplyDeleteI really think so that you should be a columnist of some good newspaper, coz whatever you write is original and interesting work. Keep going Sir, nicely done!
ReplyDeleteThanks man!! Your words mean a lot! Hopefully will also write for newspapers in future, if get a chance.
DeleteBeautifully written and explained.. keep it up
ReplyDelete